last night Andre Miller moved to 11th on the NBA All Time Assists Leaders ...

[Blueintheface]

rivalries aside, this is a good thing for Andre Miller. I'm surprised that it hasn't even been mentioned in any SLC media outlets. Maybe they're waiting for him to break the top 10?

Also, I agree with UD's comment earlier. If Jimmer can stay in the league half as long as Miller has then he will have been a great success.

For truly the first time in his career I lament his not playing for the Jazz. He would be a fantastic and calming addition to this psychophrenic team.

[DU Ute]

I love the irony of Ute fans using Millers longevity as a milestone. These same fans were ripping Ty Detmer for never doing anything in the NFL but holding a clipboard for 15 seasons. Whoops.

Detmer had not played in more of his team's games midway through his first season than Miller has in his whole career.

[creekster]

Detmer had not played in more of his team's games midway through his first season than Miller has in his whole career.

Well, that does it. I had been on the fence of this whole BYU vs. Utah thing but now, reading this thread and seeing this post's impeccable logic in particular, I guess I just have to concede the greatness that is Utah! Look, a basketball player played in more games than a football player! And, gosh, the same basketball player is eleventh all time in assists in the NBA! What more proof could anyone ever present to show the superiority of Utah? Could it be any plainer? My only regret is that it took Miller 15 years to rise to eleventh to allow me to see this truth.

But seriously, ladies and germs, isnt this whol line of argument a bit silly?

[Blueintheface]

Well, that does it. I had been on the fence of this whole BYU vs. Utah thing but now, reading this thread and seeing this post's impeccable logic in particular, I guess I just have to concede the greatness that is Utah! Look, a basketball player played in more games than a football player! And, gosh, the same basketball player is eleventh all time in assists in the NBA! What more proof could anyone ever present to show the superiority of Utah? Could it be any plainer? My only regret is that it took Miller 15 years to rise to eleventh to allow me to see this truth.

But seriously, ladies and germs, isnt this whole line of argument a bit silly?

:shush:

He's the only serious one in the thread.

[MartyFunkhouser]

I love the irony of Ute fans using Millers longevity as a milestone. These same fans were ripping Ty Detmer for never doing anything in the NFL but holding a clipboard for 15 seasons. Whoops.

Yes, Ty Detmer rarely playing his entire career is exactly the same as Andre Miller playing 34.2 mpg and starting over 90% of the games played in his career.

[DU Ute]

Well, that does it. I had been on the fence of this whole BUY vs. Utah thing but now, reading this thread and seeing this post's impeccable logic in particular, I guess I just have to concede the greatness that is Utah! Look, a basketball player played in more games than a football player! And, gosh, the same basketball player is eleventh all time in assists in the NBA! What more proof could anyone ever present to show the superiority of Utah? Could it be any plainer? My only regret is that it took Miller 15 years to rise to eleventh to allow me to see this truth.

But seriously, ladies and germs, isnt this whol line of argument a bit silly?

Easy there, monkey. First, my logic is fine. My point wasn't that a basketball player (Miller) had played more games than a football player (Detmer), it was that he had sat out of far less games, even though his sport has 5 times as many games. That is a pretty reasonable response to a comparison made of the two player's careers.

Second, no one made any claims of Utah's superiority based on Andre Miller's stellar career, though I can certainly see how you could reach that conclusion.

Finally, of course it's silly, that's what makes it fun.

[MarkGrace]

rivalries aside, this is a good thing for Andre Miller. I'm surprised that it hasn't even been mentioned in any SLC media outlets. Maybe they're waiting for him to break the top 10?

Agreed. Dre has been a very good and underrated player. I suppose maybe he'll get some media coverage here when he enters the top 10, but I don't see any reason for it at 11.

[MartyFunkhouser]

Agreed. Dre has been a very good and underrated player. I suppose maybe he'll get some media coverage here when he enters the top 10, but I don't see any reason for it at 11.

I agree. 11 isn't really a significant number. When he reaches the top 10, it will get reported.

[SeattleUte]

I agree. 11 isn't really a significant number. When he reaches the top 10, it will get reported.

I disagree. Wallace Stegner could have been Utah's Faulkner, but you won't see anything commemorating him. The ony people who get any credit are LDS, and if you critiqued or were somehow opposed to LDS institutions you will be systematically precluded from the Utah history books no matter how great you may be.

[Scorcho]

double post

[Scorcho]

Agreed. Dre has been a very good and underrated player. I suppose maybe he'll get some media coverage here when he enters the top 10, but I don't see any reason for it at 11.

since I brought this up, I wasn't expecting a two page sports story. I would have settled for a tweet, simply stating that Miller surpassed Hall of Famer Lenny Wilkens on the NBA all assist list. I'd bet a lot of Utah Fans aren't aware that he is ahead of notable names like a Jerry West, Terry Porter, Nate Archibald, or Bob Cousy in all time assists.

[pellegrino]

For truly the first time in his career I lament his not playing for the Jazz. He would be a fantastic and calming addition to this psychophrenic team.

I would have taken him from day 1. Unfortunately when he was drafted the Jazz were at the top of the league and had no chance of getting him. Even so, we didn't do all that bad in that draft in picking up AK-47.

[il Padrino Ute]

I love the irony of Ute fans using Millers longevity as a milestone. These same fans were ripping Ty Detmer for never doing anything in the NFL but holding a clipboard for 15 seasons. Whoops.

Miller's 15 year career > Detmer's 15 year career. Even you can't deny this.

[il Padrino Ute]

I disagree. Wallace Stegner could have been Utah's Faulkner, but you won't see anything commemorating him. The ony people who get any credit are LDS, and if you critiqued or were somehow opposed to LDS institutions you will be systematically precluded from the Utah history books no matter how great you may be.

Oh, brother.

You chose to leave. Get the hell over it already.

[il Padrino Ute]

I would have taken him from day 1. Unfortunately when he was drafted the Jazz were at the top of the league and had no chance of getting him. Even so, we didn't do all that bad in that draft in picking up AK-47.

One knock against Miller is that he could have come to Utah had he wanted. When Stockton retired, Miller's contract with Cleveland was up and he was offered a contract to come play for the Jazz. But he was too afraid to be the guy who followed a HoF player and instead, signed with the Clippers.