Apo out 6 weeks

[doctorcoug]

I'm doing a sport med rotation right now at a D1 school (football is fcs). I'm really curious about the doctor's clearance. Generally, injuries heal in a similar time frame, but every patient is different. Is there a third party doctor that confirms this clearance? Obviously, the school has an interest in the medical redshirt. Seems like a conflict of interest.

[hostile]

I'm doing a sport med rotation right now at a D1 school (football is fcs). I'm really curious about the doctor's clearance. Generally, injuries heal in a similar time frame, but every patient is different. Is there a third party doctor that confirms this clearance? Obviously, the school has an interest in the medical redshirt. Seems like a conflict of interest.

I think for most injuries that are common to sports, the team MD provides the clearance. For schools with a medical school, this is usually a physician from the med school. For BYU, I believe there a a few guys in the community that provide (not sure if they volunteer) medical coverage. The team docs that I have known/worked with (high school, college, pro) are very concerned about the patient first. I think they try to get players back as soon as it is safely possible.

[doctorcoug]

I think for most injuries that are common to sports, the team MD provides the clearance. For schools with a medical school, this is usually a physician from the med school. For BYU, I believe there a a few guys in the community that provide (not sure if they volunteer) medical coverage. The team docs that I have known/worked with (high school, college, pro) are very concerned about the patient first. I think they try to get players back as soon as it is safely possible.

Mitch Pratte for BYU.

I understand who provides the clearance. In terms of medical redshirts, is there a third party physician that evaluates the athlete to agree/disagree with the timeframe? This case is a good example. He is given 6 weeks. Suppose he heals slow and is more like 8 weeks. Wouldn't it behoove the university to hold clearance a little bit longer to get the hardship?

I bet there are docs out there that would do this for the love of the game.

[hostile]

Mitch Pratte for BYU.

I understand who provides the clearance. In terms of medical redshirts, is there a third party physician that evaluates the athlete to agree/disagree with the timeframe? This case is a good example. He is given 6 weeks. Suppose he heals slow and is more like 8 weeks. Wouldn't it behoove the university to hold clearance a little bit longer to get the hardship?

I bet there are docs out there that would do this for the love of the game.

I'm not sure. I've never heard of it. There are certainly instances where athletes or physician seek a second opinion.

[MarkGrace]

As reported Thursday, BYU freshman wide receiver Ross Apo suffered an open dislocation of his left index finger on Wednesday that required surgery. He is expected to be out approximately six weeks, but will work to come back as soon as possible.

Apo did not play wide receiver last Saturday against Washington, but he did play on special teams. BYU officials said Friday that the original stats book the night of the game did not list him as participating but that was later corrected.

http://www.deseretnews.com/blog/19/1...Track=rss-blog

[MarkGrace]

Apparently Bronco said tonight that he thinks Apo will get a medical RS. Sounds like we won't be seeing him this year.

[Blueintheface]

Apparently Bronco said tonight that he thinks Apo will get a medical RS. Sounds like we won't be seeing him this year.

We don't need him.

[Top Ute]

Apparently Bronco said tonight that he thinks Apo will get a medical RS. Sounds like we won't be seeing him this year.

How can you get a medical redshirt when you have a redshirt year available? Or does playing a handful of snaps in the opener disqualify one from taking a redshirt year due to injury in the same year?

[HuskyFreeNorthwest]

How can you get a medical redshirt when you have a redshirt year available?

Because he played in the first game this year making his traditional redshirt year unavailable.

I'm surprised CB and Bronco haven't started calling it blueshirt.

[Blueintheface]

I'm surprised CB and Bronco haven't started calling it blueshirt.

Because Utah uses it more effectively...multiple players with 7 years of eligibility...etc, etc

[Top Ute]

Because Utah uses it more effectively...multiple players with 7 years of eligibility...etc, etc

A total of two. Why are you so bitter about it?

[YOhio]

Because he played in the first game this year making his traditional redshirt year unavailable.

I'm surprised CB and Bronco haven't started calling it blueshirt.

I don't think Apo played in the first game. IIRC, he injured the finger during camp.

[HuskyFreeNorthwest]

I don't think Apo played in the first game. IIRC, he injured the finger during camp.

Nobody likes a know-it-all.

[YOhio]

Nobody likes a know-it-all.

Then why don't they like you?

[Jarid in Cedar]

I don't think Apo played in the first game. IIRC, he injured the finger during camp.

As usual you are wrong. Injured against Washington.

My ADR6300 is having unauthorized sleepovers.