Originally posted by Jeff Lebowski
View Post
My thoughts on Custer have evolved over the years - from an incompetent idiot to one of a good soldier and basically what you wanted in a Cav Commander. The Washita was not Sand Creek - there were braves who had been raiding living in Black Kettles village. Custer even gave orders not to fire on woman and children - not that that helped.
As far as the Little Big Horn is conserned - Custer's original plan was to lay up and attack in the morning. However he thought he had been discovered and there was one over riding tactical concern in fighting Indians - DON'T LET THEM SCATTER. He felt he had to attack right then or they would get away. His plan was flawed, but the Plains Indians had never stood and fought before, so it was good in theory. The results as they say are history.
On a side note, having walked the battlefield - IMO there is no way Reno and Benteen could have come to his rescue.

Comment