PDA

View Full Version : Colt McCoy should win the Heisman



RockyBalboa
12-12-2008, 11:20 AM
But he won't. My guess is Bradford wins it...and I'd be fine with that too. All 3 candidates are worthy of the trophy. McCoy already announced he's returning for his Senior Season so he'll be the easy frontrunner next year.

But this is my reasoning as to why I'd vote for McCoy:

** He beat Bradford head to head

** He rushed for more yards than Tim Tebow

** He is on the verge of setting an alltime NCAA Completion % record.

** The game they did lose was on a last second "Harline is still open" like TD pass.

smokymountainrain
12-12-2008, 11:37 AM
But he won't. My guess is Bradford wins it...and I'd be fine with that too. All 3 candidates are worthy of the trophy. McCoy already announced he's returning for his Senior Season so he'll be the easy frontrunner next year.

But this is my reasoning as to why I'd vote for McCoy:

** He beat Bradford head to head

** He rushed for more yards than Tim Tebow

** He is on the verge of setting an alltime NCAA Completion % record.

** The game they did lose was on a last second "Harline is still open" like TD pass.

I tend to agree. I think Bradford has been a better overall passer than McCoy, but the fact that he is a rushing threat puts him over the top, IMO.

I'm starting to think Tebow will win, but in my opinion, he should come in third.